Told he needed an amputation, arena football kicker returned to play after a second opinion
Henry Nell returned to arena football less than a year after surgery to remove a rare bone cancer and save his leg.
Henry Nell was told he needed to have his leg amputated after doctors found a rare bone cancer behind his knee. He sought a second opinion, underwent surgery that spared his leg and returned to professional arena football less than a year later.
Nell, a former professional rugby player from South Africa, first noticed stiffness in his knee in 2021 and put it down to a strained muscle. In 2025, while he was kicking for the Albany Firebirds, a team trainer recommended an X-ray. The scan revealed a mass that was diagnosed as parosteal osteosarcoma, a rare, slow-growing cancer that develops on the surface of a bone.
After a local oncologist recommended amputation, Nell and his wife traveled to New York City to see Dr. Nicola Fabbri, a surgical oncologist at NYU Langone Health. Fabbri proposed removing the tumor and reconstructing the knee with donor bone and metal plates. He believed he could save the leg, but he could not tell Nell whether he would kick again.
The July 2025 operation took about 11 hours. Fabbri had to remove both the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments to take out the tumor. Nell was cleared to put weight on the leg six weeks later and, with physical therapy and strength training overseen by Fabbri, was jogging lightly and kicking within three months.
Nell returned for the Kansas Barrels’ season opener and went on to play for the Orlando Pirates. Fabbri said Nell remains cancer-free and that the risk of recurrence is low. Nell plans to play another arena football season in spring 2027 and has started practicing with a local rugby team to see what his knee can handle.






Comments