Latest Updates
Health

Mother sues Jacksonville and officer over son’s fatal shooting during mental health crisis

Melody Gissentanner alleges a Jacksonville sheriff’s officer used excessive force when he fatally shot her son, Brian Gillis, in August 2025.

By Victoria Moore · · 2 min read

News image for Mother sues Jacksonville and officer over son’s fatal shooting during mental health crisis
Audio uses your browser’s voice.

Melody Gissentanner and her attorneys announced Wednesday that she had filed a federal lawsuit against Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office Officer Caleb Bumgarner and the city of Jacksonville over the death of her son, Brian Gillis. The lawsuit alleges Bumgarner used excessive force when he fatally shot Gillis, 30, during a mental health crisis on Aug. 13, 2025.

Gissentanner called the sheriff’s office that morning to ask officers to take her son for a mental health evaluation under Florida’s Baker Act. A crisis response officer and a licensed mental health clinician went to the family’s home, where Gissentanner told them Gillis had twice been hospitalized under the law. Gillis left on foot while officers were still at the home.

Bumgarner spotted Gillis several blocks away after officers had searched for more than an hour. According to the lawsuit and body camera footage, Gillis turned toward Bumgarner while holding a knife and told him to back up before continuing to run. Bumgarner put away his Taser, drew his firearm and fired six shots. Gillis died at the scene.

The lawsuit says Gillis was running away and did not pose an imminent threat. JSO Chief Alan Parker said on the day of the shooting that Gillis pushed the knife in Bumgarner’s direction before the officer fired. The sheriff’s office described it as a large, unsheathed knife; the lawsuit calls it a paring knife with a blade about 3 inches long.

At the news conference, attorneys Andy Hale and Jason Marks argued that Bumgarner should have sought additional help and tried to de-escalate the encounter. They also questioned whether officers did enough to stop Gillis’ bleeding while waiting for rescue crews. The footage played at the news conference shows officers calling for medical assistance.

The lawsuit brings a Fourth Amendment excessive-force claim and a wrongful-death claim against the city under Florida law. It seeks compensatory and punitive damages and attorneys’ fees. The allegations have not been proven in court. The sheriff’s office said it could not comment on pending litigation.

Comments

Comments are moderated. Be civil and stay on topic. Your name is shown; your email is not collected.

Most read

  1. YouVersion launches Bible Loop app for teens after testing it in India
  2. NorthStar marks Toronto Stock Exchange listing with market opening
  3. Swapping beef for plant-based alternatives could cut emissions with little nutritional cost
  4. Vernon curling team to represent B.C. at national club championships
  5. Real Madrid 1-1 Inter live: Nerazzurre make triple change at halftime

Get the FoxDaily newsletter

The day's top stories in your inbox. Free, unsubscribe any time.