Swapping beef for plant-based alternatives could cut emissions with little nutritional cost
A global study found that replacing most beef and other ruminant meat could cut emissions substantially while limiting nutritional risks.
Replacing three-quarters of the world’s beef, lamb and other ruminant meat with plant-based alternatives could deliver about half the emissions cuts of a much broader shift away from animal products, with far less risk of nutrient shortfalls, according to a study published in Nature Food.
Researchers modeled what could happen through 2100 if plant-based alternatives gradually replaced 25%, 50% or 75% of animal products. In the most ambitious scenario, which included poultry, fish, eggs and dairy as well as ruminant meat, emissions from agriculture, forestry and other land use fell by up to 65% by 2100 compared with the study’s baseline. Much of the reduction came from gases other than carbon dioxide, including methane.
The nutritional trade-off grew as more animal foods were removed. The model projected greater risks of shortfalls in vitamin B12, folate, zinc and vitamin A, and in some scenarios calcium. Those risks varied by region and were particularly pronounced in India, Latin America, the Middle East and North Africa. Limiting the swap to meat from cattle, sheep, goats and other ruminants kept the modeled nutritional costs relatively small.
The analysis used nutrient data from 56 plant-based meat products, whose nutritional profiles vary. It did not examine essential amino acid levels or assess the costs of fortifying alternatives or distributing supplements widely. Its estimates of how much natural land could be preserved also assumed that land freed from livestock production would be allowed to regrow wild vegetation.
Study author Zhaowu Yu of Fudan University said the scenarios illustrate potential outcomes rather than predict what is feasible. He said a gradual transition would be more realistic, with policies to improve the taste, nutritional quality and affordability of alternatives and provide support for farmers.
Comments