Perth adult shop owner decries ‘poor governance’ after club bid fails again
A bid to overturn Perth council’s refusal of an LGBTQIA+ members-only club fell short despite a 3–2 vote in favour.
Pink Rabbit Adult Boutique owner Nick Needham has accused the City of Perth of poor governance after councillors failed for a second time to clear the way for a members-only LGBTQIA+ club above his Beaufort Street shop.
City officers recommended overturning the council’s July refusal of the proposed sex-on-premises venue. Three councillors backed the reversal on Tuesday night and two voted against it, but the motion needed five votes from the nine-member council. Four members were absent.
Before the meeting, officers warned that the city had already spent about $10,000 on State Administrative Tribunal proceedings and that the bill could reach $50,000 if it continued to defend the refusal.
Lord Mayor Bruce Reynolds said his opposition was “not around anyone’s sexual orientation, identity or background” but that he was “just built in a certain way” and could not approve something he disagreed with. He also said the planning framework could limit how councillors reflected community expectations in their decisions.
Councillor Chris Patten said the venue did not fit his vision for a family-friendly city, but he doubted the refusal could be successfully defended and did not want ratepayers funding a costly legal fight. Councillor Liam Gobbert said the planning scheme allowed approval with conditions and that no impact on local amenity had been demonstrated.
Needham said the absences made the vote feel unfair and argued that personal preferences were not a planning consideration. He said the city would now have to defend its refusal at the tribunal and vowed to keep pursuing the application. “We’re feeling exhausted and defeated. However, we will continue,” he said.
Comments