Opinion: The art world should stop mistaking popularity for lasting value
Art collector Charles Riva argues that auction prices and social media visibility are poor measures of which work deserves to endure.
A painting’s auction price tells us what a buyer was willing to pay. It says little about whether the work will still speak to viewers in 50 years. Art collector and dealer Charles Riva argues that the art world is losing sight of that distinction, with consequences for what museums preserve and what future generations get to see.
Global art sales rose 4 percent to $59.6 billion in 2025, according to the 2026 Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report. But auction sales of postwar and contemporary art fell for a fourth straight year, to $4.5 billion, while contemporary art alone held at $1.4 billion. A recovery in overall sales, in other words, does not mean buyers are taking more chances on newer work.
Riva says he has noticed few younger contemporary artists at recent major auctions. He sees the appeal of established names: Museum recognition and a documented body of work give buyers something concrete to assess. But if collectors mostly buy work that institutions have already endorsed, fewer emerging artists get the chance to earn that recognition.
Social media can help correct that imbalance. Riva says he has found artists on Instagram he might otherwise have missed. The trouble begins when repeated exposure passes for appreciation. He draws a similar distinction with artificial intelligence: It can help buyers research ownership histories and compare prices, but it cannot tell them why a painting moves them.
Riva’s challenge is for collectors to trust their judgment, for galleries to back artists before demand is assured and for museums to keep market enthusiasm from dictating what they show. None of that requires dismissing popular work. It requires asking what makes a work worth preserving after the attention moves on.
Comments