Opinion: Canada’s pension fund is too quick to discount climate risk
Young Canadians are challenging the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board in court over its handling of long-term climate risk.
Young Canadians have taken the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board to court, arguing that its handling of climate risk leaves contributors who will retire decades from now unduly exposed to investment losses. The Ontario Superior Court heard the case, brought with help from Ecojustice and Goldblatt Partners. The allegations put a basic question before a fund with a 75-year horizon: How much could a warming world cost its youngest contributors?
At COP31 in Turkey, negotiators dropped language about ending fossil fuel use from a revised draft as energy security and living costs competed for attention. Yet 40 major pension funds, insurers and sovereign wealth funds warned at the summit that climate change poses a systemic risk. Whatever governments decide about fossil fuels, investors still have to account for the economic damage that extreme weather can cause.
That does not mean the investment board must lead the energy transition or stop investing in oil and gas. It does mean the board should explain why its model puts the decline in the market value of its assets at about 4 per cent in a worst-case warming scenario. Norway’s sovereign wealth fund has criticized the model for producing implausibly small losses at higher temperatures, while insurer AXA has faulted it for overlooking the infrastructure that assets need to generate revenue.
Canada’s Office of the Chief Actuary has estimated that, under a business-as-usual or worst-case scenario, the hit to Canadian GDP could reach 30 per cent by 2100. That is not a forecast of pension portfolio losses, and the figures are not directly comparable. But the economic outlook matters to a pension plan whose youngest contributors may spend decades earning and saving before they retire.
The lawsuit’s outcome is not yet clear. Regardless of how the court rules, the board should explain why it considers its loss estimate credible and what the fund would face if that estimate proves too low. Younger contributors have the most time for those risks to materialize and every reason to expect a clear answer.






Comments