Opinion: Canada can spend more on younger generations without cutting benefits for all seniors
Columnist Claude Lavoie argues Canada should recover more Old Age Security from higher-income seniors and redirect savings toward younger generations.
Canada should spend more on younger generations by reducing benefits for seniors who can most afford it, not by cutting retirement programs across the board, Globe and Mail contributing columnist Claude Lavoie argues. He points to Ontario students walking out of class over cuts to tuition assistance as a sign that frustrations over who bears the cost of public policy are not confined to Europe, where young people have taken to the streets.
Population aging makes that debate more pressing. At the current immigration rate, the ratio of seniors to working-age people is projected to rise from about 30 per cent to nearly 50 per cent by 2070, according to the C.D. Howe Institute. That shift would put more pressure on programs that rely on current revenues to pay for benefits.
Lavoie’s most direct proposal is to recover a larger share of Old Age Security payments above a specified income threshold while leaving the clawback rate unchanged for seniors with lower incomes. Raising the eligibility age instead, he argues, would force some people who cannot afford to retire to remain in physically demanding jobs.
The case for targeting benefits rests in part on differences in poverty rates. Statistics Canada reports a poverty rate of 5.4 per cent among seniors, compared with 11 per cent among youth and 31.4 per cent among single working-age adults. Those figures do not erase hardship in retirement: Lavoie also proposes extra support for widows who lose household benefits even though bills such as rent and heating do not fall when a spouse dies.
Lavoie also proposes expanding the Canada Pension Plan to improve retirement income for workers without an employer plan. His broader test for future budgets is whether they show who benefits now and who will bear the costs over time. In his view, the latest federal budget did little to ease the burden on future generations.






Comments